X
Revised 11/09/2022 03:15:58

Thank you to supporters on both sides of this issue for your thoughtful consideration of our opinions.

Below in red, please find a list of assertions thoughtfully put forward by South Dakota clergy, parents, and law enforcement working together as a coalition called Protecting South Dakota Kids. Respectfully below in blue, please find the Cannabis Consumers for Liberty (CC4L) responses.

If you would like to contribute to this opinion thread, please send comments via text message to 1-605-644-5425. Please note we had a typo in the phone number that was corrected. Respectful opinions and comments will be added to the thread.

Cannabis Claims Overview

Increase in Teen Suicides: Marijuana-associated suicides in Colorado have more than doubled since legalization in 2013.
"Toxicology reports were available for 93 of the teenagers who died by suicide. Among them, 14 had marijuana in their system, six had alcohol and six had amphetamine." (source). The article does not mention how many of the 14 who tested positive for cannabis also had alcohol and/or meth in their systems. By the numbers, cannabis is not behind the rise in suicide. We surmise the cause to be poor diet, lockdowns, lack of family values in media, and a poor economy insufficient to support a family. We also suspect mental health provider abuse of surveillance technologies and bad social engineering practices.
Increase in Addiction: Marijuana and cannabis products are 10-to-40 times stronger than 40 years ago.
Since the product was largely illegal and floating around the black market, how can such a claim be validated and corroborated after the fact? Furthermore, since smoking is the main method of consumption, higher potency cannabis would result in less smoking and an increase in the quality of public health.
Decrease in Social Justice: Legalizing marijuana hurts rather than helps underserved communities.
Black Market cannabis rates are obscene. Over regulation of cannabis dispensaries inflates prices. Taking cannabis off the Black Market and reducing cannabis industry regulations reduces strain on cannabis family budgets in all communities (including under served communities).
Increase in Poisoning: Legal cannabis sold as edibles increases poisoning in children and teens.
Outlawing the methods of consumption of cannabis drives up prices and draws law enforcement away from prosecution of truly terrible substances like meth and opioids. Accidental cannabis ingestion does not present the same danger as Aspirin overdose, consuming too much water, opioid overdose, or alcohol poisoning.
Increase in Workplace Accidents: Employees who tested positive for marijuana had 55% more industrial accidents, 85% more injuries, and 75% greater absenteeism.
Cannabis' role in these accidents is not clear. We have a model for dealing with workplace accidents caused by habitual use of alcohol and/or cough syrup in the workplace. Use this model for cannabis should it prove necessary.
Increase in Human Trafficking: National media has exposed the human trafficking & black market activities in states with legalized marijuana.
A causal link between legal cannabis obtained outside the Black Market and human trafficking has not been established.
Increase in Teen Usage: Teen marijuana and cannabis usage has dramatically increased where marijuana is legal. Average age of first-time marijuana user is 14-years old.
According to the SD Standard, "Earlier this year, the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment released a report that shows the percentage of Colorado high school students who consumed cannabis at least once in the previous 30 days had decreased from 19.7% to 13.3% between 2013, the year after Coloradans voted to legalize, and 2021". (source)
Decrease in Users' Physical Health: Marijuana users have seen an increase in heart attacks, and death rates are up to four-times higher than for non-users.
The causal link between these things and cannabis has not been established. However, it is clear that smoking is not healthy, nor is eating unhealthy foods readily available in every supermarket. Cannabis prohibition drives cannabis smoking rates and increases appetite. To remedy these problems, lawmakers could incentivize healthier food options and could incentivize alternative methods of ingestion like herbal vaporization.
Increase in Auto Accidents: Traffic deaths in legal Colorado where drivers tested positive for marijuana increased 138%.
Traffic deaths may or may not be attributable to cannabis. Some other possible causes may include aging, fatigue from over working, and poor driving skills. Each of these hypotheses must be tested in a controlled environment. If it is discovered that cannabis is a cause of poor driving, we have existing models to address the problem like warning labels on cough syrup and public education initiatives.
Increase in Black Market: In 2021, legal cannabis sales were ~$25 billion while black market sales reached an estimated $75 to $80 billion.
The Black Market does not publish its revenue findings, so it is natural to question the accuracy of the figures. Taking them at face value, however, the excess Black Market sales represents a revenue opportunity for the good guys if law enforcement can keep the streets safe like they do for other such profitable industries.

Law Enforcement Statements on Cannabis

Law Enforcement stats prove legal marijuana destroys families.
Because it is illegal, if mom or dad get arrested, prosecuted, and sent to prison, prohibition, not cannabis, destroys families. In the case of a family where a capable cannabis user is fired from a job for failing a cannabis test, a family might be destroyed as per. Prohibition drives the destruction of families, arguably, while cannabis has not been proven on its own to destroy families. The causal link between cannabis and broken homes has not met any reasonable threshold of legal standards.
[Cannabis] is a drug
Cannabis is a drug, but it is not only a drug. It has uses in textiles and recreation, also. Furthermore, a drug is technically something that cures or alleviates an ailment, like vitamin D and clean water.
Marijuana is a gateway drug.
There is no credible study proving that the consumption of cannabis causes cravings for harder drugs. The reality is that the Black Market is using cannabis to cross sell other nasty products, making the need to remove cannabis from their inventories through deregulation all the more urgent.
[Cannabis is a] deadly product
This is a false claim. The documented verifiable cases of death attributable directly and solely to cannabis use are scant and none.
Marijuana use will increase crime.
There no verifiable evidence that the consumption of cannabis creates a desire of a person to commit crime.
Legal marijuana will increase marijuana-related medical emergencies.
This is a prediction lacking accompanying impact statements. Credible evidence demonstrating significant emergencies attributable to cannabis are not available.
The "Black Market and Organized Crime" will benefit from legal marijuana.
If they do, it is because of a divisive approach to the over-regulation of cannabis that has prevented the good guys - law abiding citizens - from getting into the industry. Meanwhile, the inconsistencies and misrepresentations in handling the cannabis issue have strained the relationship between the good guys and law enforcement while we import cannabis related products from Canada legally.
The illegal distribution of marijuana will increase.
Illegal distribution of cannabis will continue, Black Markets will benefit, cartels will grow revenues, and productivity will be lost searching for quality safe cannabis as long as our laws are woefully wrong on the issue.
Recreational marijuana will provide an easy avenue for juveniles to obtain it.
According to the SD Standard, "Earlier this year, the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment released a report that shows the percentage of Colorado high school students who consumed cannabis at least once in the previous 30 days had decreased from 19.7% to 13.3% between 2013, the year after Coloradans voted to legalize, and 2021". (source)
There will be an increase in juvenile use and underage consumption of marijuana.
According to the SD Standard, "Earlier this year, the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment released a report that shows the percentage of Colorado high school students who consumed cannabis at least once in the previous 30 days had decreased from 19.7% to 13.3% between 2013, the year after Coloradans voted to legalize, and 2021". (source)
Driving under the influence of marijuana will increase dramatically.
It remains to be seen how responsible cannabis use promoted through education will affect traffic accident rates.
Traffic accidents related to marijuana will increase dramatically.
It remains to be seen how responsible cannabis use promoted through education will affect traffic accident rates.
Traffic deaths related to marijuana will increase dramatically.
It remains to be seen how responsible cannabis use promoted through education will affect traffic accident rates.
The production of marijuana will increase and be readily available to everyone.
If true, prices will go down, quality and responsible use will go up, and over time the Black Market will lose control of the industry.

Workplace Claims About Cannabis

Employees who tested positive for marijuana had 55% more industrial accidents, 85% more injuries, and 75% greater absenteeism.
Certain types of jobs can most certainly require a person not be under the influence of alcohol, cough syrup, cannabis, or opiods. That does not mean the state is justified in taking away the rights of people who use cannabis outside the work place and who work in jobs not requiring such safety standards.
Accidents where at least one driver tested positive for marijuana is 32% and almost 10% of all cannabis users openly admitted to smoking and then driving.
If more people choose cannabis over alcohol, we may see a displacement in these numbers that favors public safety. Furthermore, without adequately controlled studies conducted legally by qualified people, we may never truly know the answer to this and other questions about cannabis. There are many products with warning labels for driving. Cannabis should be afforded the same consideration, and cannabis users should be afforded the same consideration as people who use cough syrup and opioids.
An alarming 50% of users with cannabis use disorder reported driving while stoned.
The propagandized term, "cannabis use disorder" would be more accurately named "cannabis overuse", which is certainly possible. However, people do turn to cannabis, alcohol, opioids, over exercising, and other means of coping as a result of trauma, marginalization, social manipulation, intrusive surveillance, and stress from fear of going to prison.
Impacting the workplace bottom line are: decreased productivity, increased worker compensation and unemployment compensation claims, high employee turnover rate and the potential for lawsuits.
Certain types of jobs can most certainly require a person not be under the influence of alcohol, cough syrup, cannabis, or opiods. That does not mean the state is justified in taking away the rights of people who use cannabis outside the work place and who work in jobs not requiring such safety standards.
THC in marijuana affects depth perception, reaction time, coordination, and other motor skills, and it creates sensory distortion.
Certain types of jobs can most certainly require a person not be under the influence of alcohol, cough syrup, cannabis, or opiods. That does not mean the state is justified in taking away the rights of people who use cannabis outside the work place and who work in jobs not requiring such safety standards. Furthermore, without adequate studies conducted legally by qualified people, we cannot properly ascertain the contents of warning labels or other means of public safety education.
Studies suggest that cannabis increases by twofold the risk of being involved in a motor vehicle accident.
Certain types of jobs or activities can most certainly require a person not be under the influence of alcohol, cough syrup, cannabis, or opiods. That does not mean the state is justified in taking away the rights of people who use cannabis outside the work place and who work in jobs not requiring such safety standards.
Indirect interaction with machinery or safety protocols could be affected as well, especially if the person's job requires speedy reaction in case of an emergency or disaster
Certain types of jobs or activities can most certainly require a person not be under the influence of alcohol, cough syrup, cannabis, or opiods. That does not mean the state is justified in taking away the rights of people who use cannabis outside the work place and who work in jobs not requiring such safety standards.
Cannabis has marked long-term effects on the brain. The most notable of these is an increase in paranoia and anxiety over time.
Many people have long-term stress, anxiety, fear, terror, and paranoia from fear of going to prison because cannabis is illegal. It is worthy of consideration that cannabis itself does not cause paranoia. Furthermore, if cannabis increases mental acuity for the detection of true criminal conspiracies in our society (or other monumentally unfair things), the perception of this criminal activity may cause unease and justified paranoia with regard to public safety.
Marijuana positivity rates are up in legal states
This assertion is like saying the sky is blue.
The more frequently someone uses, the stronger it impact their brain and ability to function.
Without adequate study performed legally by qualified individuals, we cannot validate such an assertion. In the case of alcohol, we have identified impairment, cancer, and cognitive decline as symptoms of long term use, because we have studied it under fair and transparent circumstances and can suitably warn people of the verifiable risks.

Cannabis Assertions Related to Revenue and Money

States with mature marijuana markets have a combined $71 BILLION in budget deficits. Marijuana taxes only brought in a combined $2.5 billion. The "mature" states include California, Colorado, Nevada, Oregon and Washington
The cannabis industry is not mature. It cannot be considered mature as long as the FDA's scheduling of cannabis continues to intrude on states' rights to build their markets fully. Also, there is no credible evidence suggesting a correlation between legitimate tax and fee paying cannabis establishments and a deprivation and/or mismanagement of a state's budget.
Tax revenue from marijuana accounts for less than one percent of state revenues where the drug is legal. In South Dakota, there will be ZERO tax revenue from marijuana.
This is categorically false. Cannabis revenues will filter through to employees of dispensaries, where wages will be taxed. Subsequently, the cannabis employee will spend their wages on rent, food, insurance, and other necessities which are taxed at the local, county, and state levels.
Even as marijuana markets grow in legal states, tax revenue quickly taper[s] off (Pew Trusts, 2019).
For the people who advocate for cannabis, the primary reason for cannabis legalization is not taxation, but freedom, health, and well being.
A visit to our neighbor, Denver, visually reveals the devastation recreational marijuana wreaks on its residents, its quality of life, and individuals' safety
Any visual "devastation" observed in Denver cannot be directly attributable to cannabis in an age of rising alcoholism, BLM riots, left wing defund police movements, main stream media demonization of elected administrations, lockdowns, and depraved and mismanaged economy.
While the marijuana tax revenue in California still fails to meet its target, industry proponents are pushing legislators to reduce marijuana taxes.
Over policing and over regulation increase state costs. The over regulation is straining the industry and driving up prices for consumers unfairly to support struggling state budgets. "To put it bluntly, it's like death by a 1,000 cuts, because the more regulation and more taxes coupled with the lack of funding or grant options is killing us," said Melinda Kadinger, chief operating officer and chief financial officer of Cannabis Care Wellness. "There is no real support for this industry."
..tragic realities that have resulted from recreational marijuana legalization in other states: increased crime, welfare, broken families, increased emergency room visits, and increased traffic accidents and fatalities.
It is an unsupported claim to attribute cannabis as a proximate cause of these issues in an age of an aging boomer population, rising alcoholism, BLM riots, left wing defund police movements, main stream media demonization of elected administrations, lockdowns, and depraved and mismanaged economy.
..the financial beneficiaries to recreational marijuana legalization will be drug cartels, New York Hedge Fund managers, and national pot lobby
Prohibition is not an acceptable reaction to being beaten-out of the industry through inaction, incompetent laws, and government sponsored monopolies. South Dakota's legislature had ample time to solve this issue and did not, while enterprising entrepreneurs took the risks and filled the void. It is inappropriate to use government power to secure market share. It is appropriate to create a free and fair marketplace. Law enforcement can and should be focused on prosecuting illegal business practices, truly harmful substances like meth and opioids, alcohol abuse, and violence.
If we legalize recreational marijuana in South Dakota, it gives a green light to all the drug cartels and black-market drug dealers that it's open season on our kids and families.
This is hyperbole and rhetoric.